Crying in utero

"I heard the baby cry this week," the prenatal patient remarked casually as I took her blood pressure.

"What do you mean?" I asked.

"I was lying on the couch reading a book after dinner, when I heard the baby crying," she explained, gesturing towards her belly. "For about a minute." She reported this in the same offhand way in which she had mentioned her heartburn earlier.

Of course I was skeptical. Crying is an inspiration followed by a series of convulsive expirations, where sound is produced by the air causing the vocal folds to vibrate. But there is no air in utero. The fetus 'breathes' amniotic fluid.

I generated some possible explanations. Maybe the sound was borborygmi. The television. A neighbour. The cat. A hallucination (I didn't suggest that one outright).

But the patient was adamant. She knew what she heard, and it was her baby crying in the womb.

The strange thing is, I've heard this story from patients before.

And so I did a bit of research, and found that ultrasonic evidence of crying behaviour in utero in the third trimester is well-documented in the medical literature. And the Discovery Channel has this remarkable video of a fetus crying:

However, the 'crying' refers to the series of motor events that occur. Not the sound. If there weren't an ultrasound probe letting us peek into the uterus, there'd be no indication a baby was bawling in there. It's inaudible.

There is one rare scenario where a mother can hear her unborn baby crying: vagitus uterinus. Literally "squalling uterus," the phenomenon is the audible crying of the fetus in utero when the membranes have ruptured and air has entered the uterus.

The British Medical Journal published a letter describing the phenomenon in 1933, by Dr. Matthiasson of Iceland, who attended a birth in 1908 where he, the midwife and the medical student witnessed uterine crying in a labouring woman: ". . . there was no doubt as to the origin of the crying. It sounded pitiful, and was much like the crying of a newborn child hidden under . . . an eiderdown."

I wonder how that would be for the mother - terribly bizarre, or a wonderful motivator?

It would certainly make for the best labour and delivery story ever.

Comments

[JeanMac]

I think that would break a mother's heart to hear when in labor.Fascinating post and info.

[Amy Hoogstad]

That video is amazing! I would think it would be terribly bizarre for me, and I think it would cause me to panic rather than motivate me. But, hard to say in this highly unlikely scenario!

[Nicole]

That is so interesting!! There's so much we don't know about the baby inutero, and this doesn't surprise me. We do know that babies feel pain, so they would respond to that in some way, right? Fascinating!!

[Peggikaye]

I lost one baby girl at 20 weeks. I have two sons, now 18 and 16. I am so glad that I did not know that they could cry in untero, it would have totally unnerved me! Especially with the little girl we lost!

[Amy D]

I heard my baby cry last night in the middle of the night. I tried to call the father to wake him so he could listen too, but he didn't get up (i was sleeping on elevated sofa in another room). The only thing that I could think is air somehow got into the uterus. I have been really sick and coughing so much I pee. It was right around one of my coughing fits too. at first I thought it was our other baby, but I realized it was coming from me. I know this sounds crazy but I swear it's what I heard. lasted about 1-2 mins total..including other wimpering typed noises.

[ngonzi hope]

wow that's interesting and somehow scary if it happened to me. tho it could be true that it actually happens since other rare things like hiccups also do happen in pregnancy

[Eva Lye]

My mom swears she heard me cry in utero. It must have spooked the bajeebeez out of her, because our relationship has never been quite right. Coming from a superstitious culture, she probably thought me the devil's spawn. LOL! Thank goodness, I can now assure her it was probably just "squalling uterus" phenomenon. Of course I'm still trying to figure out how to explain the two little bumps on the top of my head and my ever so slightly protruding coccyx.